Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Nasser's avatar

As an American, I don't think its a bad idea for Canada to retaliate in some form (especially industrially) but are the tariffs the same as cutting power with the intention of literally killing people? Genuine ask as a non-canadian, are the Tariffs that dangerous to the people of Canada? I enjoyed the article, but I'm seeking a little more perspective. Thank You.

Expand full comment
Devon's avatar

I have to greatly disagree with the tone and premise of this article. I don’t think you can beat empire and fascism by waging a nationalistic war with the US. I understand there are serious merits to leveraging our power in resources and the grid to move American policy makers but it has to be pointed towards some specific end. Otherising Americans into this “Yankee” dissolves the power dynamic between politicians and citizens. The language in this post also speaks on freezing and starving US citizens which in the context of a war, trade or otherwise, does not seem any different to the war crimes we decry in other conflicts. We don’t attack civilians because we understand that they are not responsible for the actions of their government. If we did believe this we would be ideologically aligned with Osama Bin Laden.

Another point of contention I have is with the argument about oil. You state that the oil embargo caused global prices to rise. Do you mean to say that if Canada leveraged some kind of embargo on the US the price of oil would rise as well? Because I believe it will which will also deeply hurt Canadians. Seems like a pyrrhic victory to me.

Finally the whole idea of borders and national identity seems utterly fruitless and harmful to any political project. The obsession with borders only serve empire and restrict the movement of labour. If we are being honest, and Trudeau himself has said as much, what defines us as Canadians is that we arnt American. In a sense he’s right and I still don’t care. I want to be a citizen of humanity with equal representation for everyone.

I appreciate your work in voicing your thoughts but I must disagree with it in its entirety.

Expand full comment
10 more comments...

No posts